A Gendered Reading Experience: Females, Gossip and Reading

A novel, which provides a narrative on a particular social issue, such as cyber bullying can have a collective effect on a large group of adolescent female readers. In understanding these effects it is important to recount the history of gendered reading and how the framework of the ‘female reader’ was formed. By investigating the predominantly female fascination with reading ‘gossip’, in conjunction with addressing the fact that adolescent readers spend more time online than others, it will become evident how the arena for cyber bullying is related to certain female reading experiences. The group of readers formed around the series Gossip Girl, exemplifies how cyber bullying continues due to negative stereotypes in literature for young women and the in-group reading tendencies of female readers.
Until the late 20th century, males typically dominated the literary world, and most popular literature was written from a male perspective. Judith Fetterley made the assertion, in her book, “The Resisting Reader“ that female readers would have to omit their femininity to enjoy, a classic novel (Rogers 340). The andocentric order, being a system of meaning which privileges masculinity and male dominance, was presumed as having “a profoundly damaging effect on women readers,” teaching females to, “identify with a male point of view” (Schweickart 534). Fetterley, as a contributor to first wave feminism, theorized that females had to “read against the grain” and be aware of the gendered frame in which they were reading (Rogers 340).
As more women were provided with opportunities to become reputable writers, more novels came into circulation that provided a female protagonist. With the increase of literacy among women, as well as more female authors writing from a feminine perspective there grew a market for female readers, as well as a smaller emphasis on reading against the grain. In 2003, the Swedish National Council for Cultural Affairs, reported that, “among adults, working-class women as well as white-collar women read more than men” (Karlsson 167). The tendency that women prefer to read in groups became evident through the popularity of book clubs on television, and more recently online. Reading in groups is attractive to women because it has been seen that women tend to spend more time and enjoy gossiping (Arluke and Levin 281). Reading groups provide a space for women to engage in discussing texts, which they feel emotionally connected to, much like gossiping.
Opposed to the traditional fictional novel, readers are drawn to other means of escapist entertainment. Females show preference towards reading material with high emotional content. Because ‘gossip’, whether malicious or friendly elicits emotional feelings, it is regarded as popular reading for women (Hermes 119-121). Many young female readers turn to blogs, such as PerezHilton,com, opposed to picking up a novel. In a study conducted at Washington State University, Professors Bettis and Roe found that most of the grade six to eight girls, whom they tested, “desire to read but lack school and personal time [to read]” (Bettis Roe 9). The lack of importance placed upon setting aside time to read novels, in collaboration with interest in entertainment news is what produces the online culture that acts as a breeding ground for cyber bullying.
The popular novel series, Gossip Girl (2007) revolves around the backstabbing and cruel nature of an anonymous blog. The series provides a narrative for the pivotal role that adolescent’s actions on the Internet play in their lives. The themes of Gossip Girl are appropriately gendered to appeal to teenage girls. The author plays into popular stereotypes and highly emotional characters. The gendered reading experience in Gossip Girl becomes problematic because it glamorizes cyber bullying, enhancing its likelihood. By perpetuating the ‘Queen Bee’ and ‘Mean Girl’ stereotypes in the female reading experience, authors indirectly encourage adolescent females to indulge in the power struggles that lead to cyber bullying. The spheres of gossiping about peers and reading in groups becomes blurred in the instance of Gossip Girl, because of the narrative, which places bullying on a pedestal, and the interactive fan base made available through social media sites. This is an example of how, “social media expands the dynamic between author, text and reader” (Lange, 409). A large portion of teenage girls participate as fans of the series, all the while it provides bad influences seen through the rise in teens making their own “Gossip Girl” anonymous blogs to engage in cyber bullying.

Works Cited
Arluke, Arnold and Jack Levin. “An Exploratory Analysis of Sex Differences in Gossip.” Sex Roles 12.3 (1985): 281-86. Print.
Bettis, Pam, and Mary Roe. “Reading Girls: Living Literate and Powerful Lives.” Research in Middle Level Education 32.1 (2008): 1-20. Print
Burgess-Proctor, Amanda, Sameer Hinduja, and Justin Patchin. Cyberbullying Research Summary Victimization of Adolescent Girls. Rep. Cyberbullying Research Center, 2009. Print.
Cagle, Erik. “E-Books: Doom Or Opportunity?” In – Plant Graphics 61.9 (2011): 26-30. ProQuest Career and Technical Education; ProQuest Research Library. Web. 28 Jan. 2012.
Gambrell, Linda B. “Issues and Trends in Literacy: Reading Literature, Reading Text, Reading the Internet: The Times They Are A’Changing.” The Reading Teacher 53.6 (2005): 588-91. Print.
Hermes, Joke. Reading Women’s Magazines: An Analysis of Everday Media Use. Cambridge, UK: Polity, 1995. Print.
Katz, Amanda. “How We Read Now; At Internet Speed, Sales of E-books Are Surging as Those of Paper Peers Struggle. How Far Will Transition to Digital Go?” The Boston Globe [Boston] 17 July 2011: 1-3. Print.
Karlsson, Lena. “Dreams of Emotional Continuity: Reading and Relating in Malous Bokklubb.” European Journal of Cultural Studies 14.2 (2011): 163-77. Print.
Keith, Susan, and Michelle Martin. “Cyber-Bullying: Creating a Culture of Respect in a Cyber World.” Reclaiming Children and Youth 13.4 (2004): 224-28. Print.
Lambert, Jill. “Blog on.” Chatelaine 2005: 96-7. CBCA Complete; CBCA Reference & Current Events; ProQuest Research Library. Web. 28 Jan. 2012 .
Li, Qing. “New Bottle but Old Wine: A Research of Cyberbullying in Schools.” Computers in Human Behavior 23.4 (2007): 1777-791. Print.
Liu, Ziming, and Xiaobin Huang. “Gender Differences in the Online Reading Environment.” Journal of Documentation 64.4 (2008): 616-26. Print.
Maczewski, Mechthild. “Exploring Identities Through the Internet: Youth Experiences Online.” Child and Youth Care Forum 31.2 (2002): 111-29. Print.
Qunqing, Huang. “Reading Outside the Library: How the Internet Has Affected Reading in China.” Information Development 20.3 (2004): 182-88. SAGE Journals. Web. 26 Jan. 2012. .
Rich, Motoko. “Literacy Debate: Online, R U Really Reading?” New York Times [NewYork] 27 July 2008, sec. A: 1-2. Print.
Rogers, Deborah. “Reading.” Encyclopedia of Feminist Literary Theory. Ed. Elizabeth Kowalewski-Wallace. New York: Garland, 1997. 339-40. Print.
Schwartz, Josh, and Stephanie Savage. “Gossip Girl – Pilot.” Gossip Girl. CW. New York, New York, Sept. 2007. Television.
Schweickart, Patrocinio P. Reading Ourselves: Toward a Feminist Theory of Reading. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins UP, 1986. Print.
Smith, Peter K., and Sonia Sharp. School Bullying: Insights and Perspectives. London: Routledge, 1994. Print.
Vandebosch, Heidi, and Katrien Van Cleemput. “Cyberbullying among Youngsters: Profiles of Bullies and Victims.” New Media & Society 11.8 (2009): 1350-371. SAGE. Web. 5 Mar. 2012. .
Von Ziegesar, Cecily. Gossip Girl: A Novel. New York: Little, Brown and, 2002. Print.
White, Emily. Fast Girls: Teenage Tribes and the Myth of the Slut. New York: Scribner, 2002. Print.
Ytre-Arne, Brita. “Women’s Magazines and Their Readers: The Relationship between Textual Features and Practices of Reading.” European Journal of Cultural Studies 14.2 (2011): 213-28. Print.